Ed Markey Defeats Seth Moulton!

Age ain't nothing but a number. Progressives want fighters. Ed Markey is a fighter.

The moderates are not winning all their races. Looks like his presidential and senatorial hopes were crushed again. Massachusetts voters despite frustrations with their two senators, they are satisfied with the work they're doing.

Mind you, the frustrations are that senators are too damn old, too willing to stay in their lane and protect the status quo.

Sen. Ed Markey (D-MA) fends off a primary challenger from the middle. He easily defeats Rep. Seth Moulton (D-MA) in a race to determine whether Massachusetts voters had enough of old man Markey.

What cost Moulton his primary win was the anti-trans remarks. Moulton publicly claimed Democrats lost in part due to their stance on transgender issues, stating he didn't want his daughters "getting run over on a playing field by a male or formerly male athlete". In debates, Markey heavily weaponized these comments, accusing Moulton of "throwing trans kids under the political bus". Despite a late-stage apology from Moulton, the issue firmly consolidated progressive voters and LGBTQ+ advocacy groups behind Markey.

Moulton faced intense scrutiny after it was revealed he only rebuked and returned funding from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) after the group refused to guarantee an endorsement for his Senate run. This deeply damaged his credibility with younger, progressive anti-war voters in the state.

In the final weeks of the primary saw intense debates over national security, defense spending, and Middle East conflicts—including positions on a potential war with Iran. Markey successfully framed himself as the anti-establishment choice, utilizing high-profile endorsements from progressive icons like Senator Bernie Sanders and Senator Elizabeth Warren to overcome voters' concerns about his age (80).

Markey successfully pointed to Moulton’s more moderate positions to argue that it was Moulton — not the older incumbent — who was out of touch with the state’s voters.

Markey had boasted about his 2022 climate bill and called for an end to the war in Iran to bring down energy costs. He also sharply criticized Moulton for opposing “Medicare for All” — though Moulton called for universal healthcare.

“He has a backwards-looking political agenda,” Markey said.

In heavily Democratic Massachusetts, the primary is considered the most critical election hurdle, and the winner is expected to prevail in the general election in November.

Markey has been a fixture in Massachusetts politics since the 1970s, prompting Moulton to make his “status quo” arguments on the campaign trail and to question Markey’s accomplishments during his lengthy time in office.

In a concession speech, Moulton said he would now support Markey.

“Challenging the establishment and calling for a new generation of leadership isn’t easy. But it is necessary,” Moulton told supporters. “We started conversations that needed to happen.”

“We didn’t achieve our goal tonight, but I am confident others will be inspired to buck the system when they’re told to wait their turn,” he added.

The Senate race was not the only generational challenge for Democrats on Tuesday’s ballot. A similar dynamic played out in the 8th Congressional District, where Patrick Roath hoped to oust longtime incumbent Rep. Stephen Lynch, and in the 1st Congressional District of western Massachusetts, where progressive public school teacher Jeromie Whalen faced against Rep. Richard Neal.

Wagers on whether he gets a gig on Fox, CNN or Newsnation. Seth Moulton gives up a safe seat for a risky gamble. He loses.

Moulton’s comments on transgender children were an issue

During the campaign Markey repeatedly pointed out that Moulton, in 2024, raised eyebrows among some in the party for saying he did not want his daughters playing sports against transgender girls.

Critics said he was echoing President Donald Trump’s talking points against allowing transgender athletes in girls’ and women’s sports.

Moulton later apologized for his remarks, saying it was not his intention to hurt the transgender community and stressing his support for other transgender rights bills.

“If you’re in the trans community or you’re a trans kid feeling the weight of the Trump administration and the Supreme Court, you matter,” Moulton said during an August debate. “You’re valued, and I will always have your back.”

Moulton, who enlisted in the Marines after the attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, and served four tours of duty in Iraq, was first elected to Massachusetts’ 6th Congressional District in 2014. He launched a 2020 presidential campaign but dropped it after a few months.

Markey was elected to the Senate in 2013. Before that he represented Massachusetts’ 7th Congressional District from 1976 to 2013.

Markey notably fended off a challenge in 2020 from Rep. Joe Kennedy III, a younger rival from one of the nation’s most famous political families. Markey did so by aligning himself with the liberal wing of the Democratic Party.

Antoine Hilaire, a 76-year-old Democrat who voted for Markey in Brockton on Tuesday, said being older can be a positive because it offers people experience and wisdom.

“If the older one is doing the better job, I don’t know,” he said. “He’s doing a good job. It’s not a big, big, big problem.”

Longtime Democratic House incumbents also face younger challengers

Lynch, 71, has held the 8th District seat in south Boston since 2001. He faced Roath, a 39-year-old lawyer who contended that it is time to end “wait-your-turn” politics. Lynch stressed the value of experience inside Congress.

Lynch has fended off other youth challenges in the past, but Roath’s campaign hoped for a boost of excitement after longtime Democratic incumbent U.S. Rep. John Larson was defeated by former Hartford Mayor Luke Bronin in August in neighboring Connecticut. Like Roath, Bronin called for the need for generational change while running against an establishment politician.

Meanwhile the 1st District primary in western Massachusetts pitted Neal, 77, against Whalen, 39.

Neal, known as the dean of the New England House delegation, was first elected in 1988. Whalen ran to the left of Neal, calling for Medicare for All and questioning whether Neal has done enough to oppose Trump’s agenda.

Whalen recently was endorsed by Our Revolution, a progressive organization founded by Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont.